Published September 14th, 2022 at 4:41 pm, Last Updated September 15th, 2022 at 4:42 pm
So what is a zombie idea? According to a paper written by an international research team examining water conservation, A zombie idea is one that has been repeatedly refuted by analysis and evidence, and should have died, but clings to life for reasons that are difficult to understand without further investigation.
The belief that modern irrigation technologies can save significant amounts of water drives billions of dollars of investments into modern irrigation technologies every year. To find out why the perception that investment in complex modern irrigation systems saves water continues to resurrect itself zombie style, the international research team reviewed more than 200 supporting research articles on drip, sprinkler and traditional water systems. Their research paper Agricultural water saving through technologies: a zombie idea was published in the peer-reviewed journal Environmental Research Letters in November 2021.
The team looked at how this zombie idea forms; why it persists, even when proven wrong by scientific evidence; and how to overcome it. The international team included: Frank Ward, Department of Agricultural Economics, New Mexico State University; C Dionisio Prez-Blanco, Department of Economics, Universidad de Salamanca, Spain; Adam Loch and David Adamson, School of Economics and Public Policy, Centre for Global Food and Resources, The University of Adelaide, Australia; and Chris Perry, Consultant, London, UK.
Flood Irrigation Has History Here
Agriculture in the Rio Grande floodplain has been significant since prehistoric times. Water is a very scarce resource in the high mountain deserts of New Mexico and farming techniques have not changed much in thousands of years. Traditional irrigated farming remains the most important form of agriculture across the state.
Native Americans were the first inhabitants in the Land of Enchantment and various Tribes and Pueblos farmed and hunted on the land the Rio Grande flowed through for at least 10,000 years before Europeans came. The river supported more than 100 Pueblos with well-developed and sophisticated water harvesting and irrigation techniques in place centuries before the Spanish and the Mexican settlers arrived. The new settlers brought with them the communal irrigation and management structure associated with the current acequias irrigation systems.
The King of Spain, and later the Governor of New Mexico, bestowed land grants to individuals based on prior service or loyalty from the 1600s through the 1800s. These grants usually contained sufficient land and water resources to facilitate settlement and the establishment of communities. Many of New Mexicos acequia systems are legally defined within those land grants. There are a total of 295 land grants recognized in New Mexico and at least 700 acequia irrigation systems.
Each influx of settlers into New Mexico expanded or constructed the acequia systems until they stretched into the San Juan Basin, the San Luis Valley of southern Colorado and the tributaries of the Canadian water river in the east. The communal approach to water distribution, shared equally, evolved further in response to drought.
Modernizing New Mexicos Irrigation Systems
The concept of modernizing New Mexicos nearly 700 acequia irrigation systems to save water is an intriguing one. According to the latest available state engineer report, irrigation accounted for 76% of water withdrawals in New Mexico in 2015. With climate change, population growth and drought increasing daily, upgrading the acequia system to a drip irrigation or sprinkler system is an idea that many might think makes a lot of sense. The research team found out it does not.
The team found the assumption that modern irrigation technologies save water, has been refuted by analysis and evidence, should be dead yet it lives on. They said the impacts of complex modern irrigation systems usually have the opposite effect to what was intended. Any water saved is likely to be at the expense of return flows to aquifers or drains. If these are a source of water to other users, any local benefits are largely offset by negative impacts elsewhere.
NMSU Research Team Member Weighs in on Research
The Paper spoke with research team member Frank Ward, distinguished achievement professor at New Mexico State Universitys College of Agricultural, Consumer and Environmental Sciences.
Water conservation is very hard to measure as everyone has their own view on what water conservation is. Drip irrigation is very attractive to some because it applies much, much less water than surface or flood irrigation. It also costs a lot. The drippers need cleaning, the animals get in. Its a mess, Ward said.
He said people typically do drip irrigation on a very small scale, or for very high value crops, as it can be quite profitable. The only problem with drip is, when you grow your crops with drip irrigation, your yields and production per acre go up. In a dry place like New Mexico the problem with higher crop yields is they very often give rise to higher water consumption.
Ward explained that though you apply less water under drip than you do in traditional irrigation, you actually consume more water as the yields and production go up. And, there is reduced recharge into the aquifer basin around Albuquerque.
Historically there is an assumption that shifting into drip irrigation will conserve water, but very, very few studies have been done that have measured that, and those that have measured it have found that in a lot of cases it can increase water consumption.
It can increase income and increase yield. Its good for food security, you get more calories into peoples bellies. But it doesnt necessarily conserve water. The water that would have gone down into the land to recharge the aquifer basin under flooding irrigation, disappears or nearly disappears, he said.
The Rio Puerco watershed, located beneath the The Navajo Chapter community of ToHajiilee, 30 miles from Albuquerque and completely within the Middle Rio Grande Underground Water Basin, ran out of water twelve years ago, What water remains is filled with corrosive dissolved solids, looks like orange juice, resembles coffee grounds and smells like rotten eggs.
Ward said people are looking at legislative enactments and proposals on subsidizing drip irrigation to combat water shortages. The researchers concluded abandoning the zombie idea that conversions to modern irrigation technologies will save water is a prerequisite to achieving sustainable water and economic security.
The research teams paper states: If the objective is saving water, resources are better employed in researching and testing the feasibility and performance of transition pathways towards transformational institutions and policies that are effective in saving water (such as quotas or charges), rather than in subsidizing modern irrigation technologies that increase consumption and aggravate scarcity.
South Valley Farmer Weighs in on Water Use
I spoke with Marcia Fernandez who has a small farm in the South Valley that is both irrigated from the Rio Grande and also has drip irrigation from their well. Fernandez said there is a misconception that farmers are wasting all the water.
A county commissioner said we need to go to drip irrigation. To which I say, you cant drip irrigate all crops. You might be able to drip irrigate a cornfield or potato field or a chili field with a lot of money, but you cant irrigate pasture or alfalfa or crops that you feed to animals, Fernandez said.
Fernandez uses drip irrigated groundwater that comes out of a well for their garden. Your yields are very good with drip irrigation. You have good control of how much water youre bringing from underground, however the water you are bringing up is highly mineralized water that includes a huge number of salts. Most of them are calcium salts, but there are others and your ground eventually becomes unusable and unreliable.
Fernandez said once youve added the salts as a foreign element to the dirt your crops yields will ultimately go down. The dirt becomes literally white from the calcium build up and it looks like you have thrown flour on your dirt and thats a big problem. We drip irrigate what we can and we flood irrigate the rest when theres water, she said. The water from flood irrigating is returned through groundwater absorption into the shallow aquifer, which eventually makes its way to the deep aquifer.
When the Rio Grande went dry in July, it was a big moment for the Middle Rio Grande acequias. We asked the Water Utility Authority to declare a stage three water emergency which would mean no outdoor watering, but they just looked at us and said: You guys are crazy. We have enough water for 100 years.
Thats literally how they are viewing this, Fernandez said. The utility authority doesnt ascribe to the Native wisdom that you need to consider the results of your actions for seven generations after you. Why are they not panicking about it? Their hair should be on fire about this, but its not.
Fernandez has had the hills and slopes of their land scanned with a laser and leveled for more efficient irrigating. Theres a lot of work and money involved in maintaining drip irrigation as the salt accumulates inside of the drippers and other equipment, and they have to be replaced frequently. Fernandez said the city of Albuquerque and Rio Rancho and others who have their straws in the deep aquifer are beholden to the people who are helping recharge the aquifer as the figures of recharge to the river now are pretty low. She said the farmers that flood irrigate are contributing huge amounts of water to the deep aquifer and she advocates paying the farmers of cultural lands and the Pueblo of Sandia for recharging the aquifer.
We are helping to keep the aquifer of Albuquerque afloat. Peoples lands are laser leveled. We are required to finish irrigating one acre in one hour. The farmers dont waste water, were not running water out into wastelands, were not running water over roads or have sprinklers watering the sidewalk, she said. Farmers have done a good job of using just what they need and no more.
More:
A Zombie Idea: Saving Agricultural Water Through Technology - The Paper.
- The R-Rated Zombie Horror Comedy That Created Eating Brains, Stream Without Netflix - Giant Freakin Robot - July 25th, 2024
- Thousands of homeowners could face foreclosure over "zombie" mortgages. Here's what to know - CBS News - July 25th, 2024
- America's $5 billion zombie industry: By the numbers - The Week - July 25th, 2024
- Opinion | The Zombie Law That Threatens Abortion Access - Medpage Today - July 25th, 2024
- What Is The Best Zombie Game You've Played So Far? - GameRant - July 25th, 2024
- Thousands of homeowners could face foreclosure over "zombie" mortgages. Here's what to know - Yahoo! Voices - July 25th, 2024
- Kid Rocker students perform "Zombie" by The Cranberries - KOLO - July 25th, 2024
- Far Cry goes full horror in this free zombie mod - GAMINGbible - July 25th, 2024
- This George Romero-Inspired Horror Is a Wholesome Tale of a Boy and His Zombie - Collider - July 25th, 2024
- This South Korean Zombie Movie Restored Quentin Tarantinos Faith in the Undead - Dread Central - July 25th, 2024
- The power bank that could survive a zombie apocalypse - Popular Science - July 25th, 2024
- QUEENS OF THE DEAD: Katy OBrian To Star In Tina Romeros Queer Zombie Comedy - FANGORIA - July 25th, 2024
- Zombie 2nd mortgages are coming to life, threatening thousands of Americans' homes - WFAE - May 20th, 2024
- Spam, junk slop? The latest wave of AI behind the zombie internet - The Guardian - May 20th, 2024
- 'Zombie cells' in the sea: Viruses keep the most common marine bacteria in check - Phys.org - May 20th, 2024
- 'Zombie Driver' Prompts Wild Police Chase From Venice Onto 405 that Ends in Crash - Los Angeles Magazine - May 20th, 2024
- What are zombie fires, and why are they becoming more common? - KXAN.com - May 20th, 2024
- "Zombie" Wildfires Force Thousands To Evacuate In Western Canada - DOGOnews - May 20th, 2024
- What exactly are 'zombie' fires, and how are they affecting wildfires this spring? - CBC News - May 20th, 2024
- The Case of the Zombie Ninjas - East County Magazine - May 20th, 2024
- Zombie' fires partially to blame for spring Canadian wildfires - NBC Connecticut - May 20th, 2024
- What are 'zombie fires'? - Fox Weather - May 20th, 2024
- Kill the zombie Space National Guard idea - Defense One - May 20th, 2024
- AIs Flirty Upgrade, Facebooks Zombie Internet, and Why We May Be Doing Mental Health Wrong - Crooked - May 20th, 2024
- What are zombie fires, and why are they becoming more common? - KTVI Fox 2 St. Louis - May 20th, 2024
- Zombie Cicadas taking over the trees... and your plate? - Gray DC - May 20th, 2024
- Canada's "zombie" wildfires threaten towns, send smoke into U.S. - Axios - May 20th, 2024
- 10 Best Zombie Movies of the 21st Century, Ranked - Collider - May 20th, 2024
- Zombie cicadas are taking over the trees... and your kitchen! - Gray DC - May 20th, 2024
- 'Zombie' entrepreneurs who can't afford to close down is on the rise in S.Korea - - May 20th, 2024
- The 10 best zombie games to play in 2024 - TechRadar - May 20th, 2024
- 'Zombie' house flippers discover the grisly past of Florida home - ABC Action News Tampa Bay - May 20th, 2024
- Resident Evil collides with Battlefield in this WW1 zombie horror - GAMINGbible - May 20th, 2024
- What is a zombie fire? | Latest Weather Clips - Fox Weather - May 20th, 2024
- What are 'zombie' fires, and why are they becoming more common? - MSN - May 20th, 2024
- Transformers' New Zombie Autobot Is a Sick Way to Treat the Hero Who Relaunched the Franchise - Screen Rant - May 20th, 2024
- #Showbiz: A clutch of zombie movies with bite - New Straits Times - May 20th, 2024
- 'Zombie' wildfires resurface in Canada, worsening US air quality - The Times of India - May 20th, 2024
- The Last of Us Season 2 First Look: Pedro Pascal and Bella Ramsey Return to Face the Zombie Apocalypse - Variety - May 20th, 2024
- On its 15th anniversary, Killing Floor stands as one of the best zombie shooters and the timing couldn't be more ... - VG247 - May 20th, 2024
- The HANDLING THE UNDEAD Trailer Imagines A Different Kind Of Zombie Movie - FANGORIA - May 9th, 2024
- Museum in Germany Finds Skeleton That May Have Been Considered a Zombie - Atlas Obscura - May 9th, 2024
- The Dead Don't Die Brilliantly References Bill Murray's Other Zombie Movie With 89% On RT - Screen Rant - May 9th, 2024
- Austin Butler's 2019 Zombie Movie Marked The End Of A Concerning RT Trend - Screen Rant - May 9th, 2024
- 'Quality and Diversity': From Zombie Apocalypse to 'Vengeful Quinceaera,' Blood Window Showcase Presents Six ... - AOL - May 9th, 2024
- Zombie Trainers and a New Era of Forced Labor - Newsweek - May 9th, 2024
- I Started A Zombie Outbreak In Undead Inc And I Regret Nothing - TheGamer - May 9th, 2024
- How to watch the Night of the Living Dead and all of George Romero's zombie movies - Popverse - May 9th, 2024
- The Cranberries' Zombie - the story behind the incendiary song - Louder - April 22nd, 2024
- Chris Riddell on the zombie Tory government falling apart at the seams cartoon - The Guardian - April 22nd, 2024
- Zombie grave dating back 4,200 years discovered in Germany, photos show - Miami Herald - April 22nd, 2024
- Steam zombie survival game leaves early access 11 years on, and you've got one week to get it cheap - PCGamesN - April 22nd, 2024
- "Zombie" cicadas with STDs are coming to Virginia - Axios - April 22nd, 2024
- Deathtroopers is the Star Wars zombie horror game I never knew I needed - PC Gamer - April 22nd, 2024
- Zombie Army VR Reveals The Story In Latest Trailer - Bleeding Cool News - April 22nd, 2024
- Where Infected "Zombie Cicadas" In The US Will Emerge In 2024 - TheTravel - April 22nd, 2024
- Zombie anti-abortion laws are menacing American women - The Hill - April 22nd, 2024
- Joe Manganiello to Zombie It Up in Mountain Man Adaptation - Reactor - Reactor - April 22nd, 2024
- Frozen Soul Covered White Zombie and It Rules - MetalSucks - April 22nd, 2024
- Arizona's abortion ban could bring zombie laws back to life in other states - Fast Company - April 22nd, 2024
- Arizona abortion ban shows the dangers of reviving zombie laws - MSNBC - April 22nd, 2024
- Zombie fires smoldering near Canadian oil and gas wells threaten production following 2023 wildfires - WorldOil - April 22nd, 2024
- You'll Never Guess Who Doesn't Want to Repeal a Zombie Abortion Ban - The New Republic - April 22nd, 2024
- Zombie Army VR: New trailer gives a glimpse of the gruesome campaign - MIXED Reality News - April 22nd, 2024
- Zombie Tests: Is the SAT Back From the Dead? - Fair Observer - April 22nd, 2024
- How likely are you to survive a zombie apocalypse in Connecticut? You may want to travel north - Hartford Courant - April 22nd, 2024
- Missouri Reports 162 New Cases Of Deer 'Zombie' Disease In 2023 - Lake Expo - April 22nd, 2024
- Zombie Fires Pose Looming Threat to Canada's Oil and Gas Infrastructure - OilPrice.com - April 22nd, 2024
- Rob Zombie Presenting House on Haunted Hill Soundtrack on Vinyl - ComicBook.com - April 22nd, 2024
- Take on Zombie Stormtroopers In This Star Wars Fan Game - IGN - April 22nd, 2024
- The Best Zombie Game of 2023 Has a New Expansion Out Now - Esports.net News - April 22nd, 2024
- Frozen Soul Debuts Frosty Rendition of White Zombie's 'Creature of the - Knotfest - April 22nd, 2024
- 'Dawn of the Dead' at 45: A Zombie Love Affair That Never Died - The New York Times - April 12th, 2024
- Hyper-sexual 'zombie cicadas' infected with bizarre STD fungus will emerge in US - New York Post - April 12th, 2024
- Zombie malls and other retail centers getting extreme makeovers to keep up with the times - Chicago Tribune - April 12th, 2024
- 'Zombie' drug xylazine found in cannabis THC vapes in UK - BBC.com - April 12th, 2024
- Taxing health insurance: The Republican zombie that refuses to die - Roll Call - April 12th, 2024
- Fungus-infected Zombie Cicadas with hypersexuality to emerge in the US this year: Expert - Hindustan Times - April 12th, 2024
- Zombie Classic Dawn Of The Dead Coming Back to Theaters for 45th Anniversary - MetalSucks - April 12th, 2024
- E-News | 'Zombie cicadas' infected with sexually transmitted fungus expected to emerge this year in parts of US - WVU ENews - April 12th, 2024
Reviewed and Recommended by Erik Baquero